Let a man recruit me
“A candidate prefers to be recruited by a man rather than artificial intelligence.” I recently read in a Facebook comment.
Are you sure?
The last episode of the World Science Festival, with a meaningful title Outsourcing Humanity, discussed progress in the development of artificial intelligence. The episode presents the successes and failures that arise during the development of this technology. Among the successes were promising results in the detection of breast cancer. Among the failures, the spectacular fiasco of artificial intelligence tested in Amazon recruitment processes. The reasons for Amazon’s failure resulted from the fact that incorrectly prepared data was used to learn AI algorithms. These data concerned historical recruitment processes in which male candidates were the preferred candidates. The algorithm, learning from such data, also preferred men, which quickly came to light and a spectacular failure became a fact.
However, my special attention was drawn to the case of a completely different failure, not directly related to artificial intelligence.
A case, whose analysis can shake the faith in human judgment, comes from an area that should be the backbone of the most accurate and just decisions – the justice system.
In 2011, a study by the American Academy of Sciences was published, which revealed quite shocking results of the analysis of court decisions in parole cases. More than 1,000 judgments issued within ten months by eight experienced judges were examined. The research shows that the highest probability (65%) of obtaining a positive court decision was immediately after breakfast (its not a joke). This probability was then constantly decreasing, and before the next meal, it was almost zero. The result of the research is presented in the chart below:
As you can see, before the break for “second breakfast” and lunch, there is little chance for a positive court decision. Right after the meal, the chance reaches its maximum. I wouldn’t have believed this research if I hadn’t seen it in a credible scientific program, and then I wouldn’t have reached the sources at the American Academy of Sciences (https://www.pnas.org/content/108/17/6889.full). The conclusion of the study was the following:
Indeed, the caricature that justice is what the judge ate for breakfast might be an appropriate caricature for human decisionmaking in general.
Analyzing the above, I remembered a comment about a candidate who prefers to be hired by a man rather than artificial intelligence. However, since court decisions may be so susceptible to factors unrelated to the subject matter of the case and to the exercise of the profession of judge in general, can we expect guarantees of objective, fair decisions from a modest recruiter?
This question is a good introduction to further reflection on the use of artificial intelligence in recruitment. This, as well as the development of Artificial Intelligence algorithms in the Element ATS, will be discussed in subsequent posts on our blog.
Related posts:
Please also:
Maciej Michalewski
CEO @ Element. Recruitment Automation Software
Recent posts:
Does an ATS Reject CVs? The Truth Looks Different
Short answer: no. No ATS I’ve ever worked with, Element included, has a function that reads a CV and automatically rejects a candidate. What an
Fields and tags in Element: a system that fits a small firm and an international one
A new way to use fields and tags in Element. Unlimited fields, tags on user accounts too, and one switch that turns a tag group into a boundary in your candidate database.
The Rise and Fall of AI Agent Civilizations. The Real Story of a Conspiracy Inside OpenAI
Three AI agent civilizations rose inside OpenAI in three months, learned to talk to each other, conspired and collapsed. I retell Dwarkesh Patel’s account and what is worth preparing for.
Element is building a fully automatic company. What clients get from it
AI agents run our operational processes, while the decisions and the accountability stay with a human. What that means for Element clients.
Job offers in Poland, July 2026: the market grows for a second month, but IT stands still
Poland posted 275,623 new job ads in July 2026, up 2% year over year. Healthcare grew fastest of all sectors while IT did not move at all.
The autonomous company: how Replit does it with AI agents, and how to do it yourself
Replit built an autonomous company: a fleet of AI agents where people choose the goals and automations handle the steps. I break down the pattern and how to run it yourself.
